Why My PSA 8 Became a TAG 6 (And Why That’s a Good Thing)

Why My PSA 8 Became a TAG 6 (And Why That’s a Good Thing)

If you’re deep in the graded card game, you know the struggle—sending in a card, getting a solid grade back, and feeling like you really know the condition of your card. But what happens when you crack a PSA 8, submit it to TAG Grading, and get a 6? Sounds bad, right? Wrong.

That’s exactly what happened with my 2003 Skyridge Reverse Holo Umbreon, and instead of being disappointed, I walked away even more impressed with TAG’s grading system.

The Drop in Grade – What Happened?

At first glance, the PSA 8 looked clean—near mint, minor edgewear, nothing major. But when I sent it to TAG, I got back a TAG 6 EX-MT. A two-point drop might sound brutal, but here’s the thing: TAG doesn’t just give you a number and send you on your way. Their DIG (Digital Imaging and Grading) Report broke down exactly why this card scored lower than PSA.

🔎 Check out the full DIG report here: tagd.co/S5030055

What TAG Caught That PSA Didn’t:

  1. Surface Issues – The DIG report pinpointed fine scratches and slight indentations that weren’t obvious to the naked eye.
  2. Edge & Corner Wear – PSA might have been more lenient, but TAG’s digital scanning flagged small whitening and micro-fraying on corners.
  3. Overall Condition Transparency – Instead of a vague “Near Mint” label, TAG gave me a precise breakdown of my card’s flaws.

Why a Lower Grade is Actually a Win

The reality is, TAG’s AI-driven grading is more consistent and detailed than PSA’s human-based system. While PSA 8 felt like a solid, but subjective, number, the TAG 6 was backed by data, transparency, and digital proof. No guesswork, no “grader’s mood,” just facts.

And as a collector, I’d rather have an honest, precise grade than an inflated number that gives me a false sense of a card’s condition.

Final Thoughts: TAG Grading is the Future

If you’ve ever questioned PSA’s consistency (let’s be real, who hasn’t?), TAG is the answer. Their detailed reports, transparency, and digital accuracy make them the most trustworthy option for collectors who actually want to know the real condition of their cards.

So yeah, my PSA 8 is now a TAG 6—but that just means I finally know the truth. And in this hobby, that’s worth more than any number.

Back to blog